S&P 500 fair value

US equities · Valuation and scenarios · Weekly

Loading.


Today

Table Earnings of the index, in index points, and the multiple each implies


Scenarios

Exhibit 1 What the index would be worth if one thing changed. Click a row to load it into the model below.

Exhibit 2 Index level by earnings and multiple. Multiples are percentiles of the trailing price to earnings ratio since 1990.


The model

Load

The page opens on what is priced: the premium is the one that makes the model equal the index. Growth is in real terms and inflation is added to it, so inflation raises the discount rate and the growth of cash flows together. Payout is not an input: it is the share of earnings left after retaining enough to fund growth at the chosen return on equity.

n/aFair value, two-stage
n/aFair value against index level
n/aValue in twelve months
n/aImplied equity risk premium at index level
n/aDiscount rate (cost of equity)
n/aFair multiple of trailing earnings
n/aNominal growth, stage 1 then long run
n/aPayout ratio, stage 1 then long run
n/aShare of value from terminal value
Exhibit 3 Fair value across the discount rate (rows) and long-run nominal growth (columns). In brackets, the gap to the index level. The shaded cell is the current input set.
Exhibit 4 Fair value against the discount rate. Grey horizontal line: index level. Dashed vertical line: current discount rate.
Exhibit 5 Equity risk premium implied at each index level. Grey horizontal line: the premium set in the inputs. Dashed vertical line: the index level.

History

Exhibit 6 Earnings yield of the index, 10-year real Treasury yield, and the gap between them, percent, monthly

Exhibit 7 Price to trailing earnings and price to ten-year average real earnings (CAPE), monthly

Multiples above 50 are left out: reported earnings collapsed in 2008 and 2009 and the trailing multiple passed 100.


Data


Limits

Analyst estimates are optimistic on average and are revised down more often than up; the valuation takes them as they are. Analyst earnings exclude items companies call non-recurring and run above reported (GAAP) earnings, shown beside them. Most of the value is in the distant future. The scenarios change one or a few things and hold the rest still, which markets do not do. The gap between the earnings yield and the real yield has a history that starts in 2003 and includes a decade of very low real yields, which makes today look expensive against it.

Educational research. Not investment advice. This is not an official release of any institution.